Recently I’ve been learning about
something called one-upmanship. It has a bona fide dictionary definition:
“the
technique or practice of gaining a feeling of superiority over another person.”
I’m sad to say that a lot of people actually view one-upmanship as an art, a
technique they can add to their life skills list on their resume. You’ve
probably experienced a conversation at some point in your life with someone who
practices one-upmanship. It might have looked something like this…
![]() |
| Click on image to view the original. |
The cartoon is funny and pretty realistic, in my opinion, of the
condition of one-upmanship. Battling for advantage in a conversation like two
macaws fighting for their colors to be loudest. It sounds quite funny when you
read through this conversation of two bickering kings, sounding much like two
young girls squabbling over whose Barbie is better. But, when it comes down to
it, it is a very serious thing. It’s a very serious spiritual matter of pride.
And, ladies, we need to pay attention.
One-upmanship is the condition where we as women secretly (or not so secretly) conspire to one-up another woman’s accomplishment. I say secretly because pride typically likes to remain hidden in our thoughts and hearts. But, as many of us have probably experienced, pride also likes to dance upon the blade of a dangerous weapon we all have—the tongue. For me personally my pride tends to be internally spoken—not externally, from the tongue. This almost seems more difficult and potentially dangerous to me because it doesn’t allow opportunities to be challenged by listening Christian sisters, hearing my prideful thoughts spoken aloud. However, pride is pride and it’s a dangerous trap in our spiritual lives.
As women, or just human beings in general, we desire recognition, love, adoration, and to be treated with high regard. We want other people to recognize our worth and our talents. Are these things all bad? Not necessarily. But, when we start to compare our work to that of others, we ought to be watchful lest a cunning thing called jealousy walks into our hearts.
I like to think of jealousy as
the cohort of pride. Jealousy is by nature selfish. We like to feel important,
and jealousy is the process of questioning and confirming our own
self-importance. Likewise, pride tells us that we are more important, that we
are the most important. The one-upper
condition most distastefully combines both self-centered, sinful tendencies. It
causes us to look at another person’s work (whatever it might be), compare it
to our personal superior ability to do that same work, and desire the same
attention the other person is getting. One-uppers want the satisfaction of the
best finished product.
For me, I’ve seen my one-upper
mentality come through with baking. Yes, baking. As silly as it might sound, it's a pride issue. I want my dessert to be the best at the
party. I want people to rave about it for days afterwards. When I know of other
“bakers” coming to the party, I anxiously immerse myself in searching and
formulating the BEST atypical recipe. There’s bound to be chocolate chip
cookies, I think, so I’m going to wow them with something richer, more
chocolate-y, gooier, more delicious… And, I can think of numerous other works
where one-upmanship can come into play: hosting, event planning, home
cleanliness, personal thriftiness, your wardrobe, your child-rearing, craftiness, car buying (or
any purchasing), your personal creativity, hygiene, career success… the list
goes on and on. So, where do you tend to be a one-upper?
(Now, I’m not saying that we can’t
accidentally one-up someone. It’s definitely possible to unintentionally be one
step ahead of someone else. You can be better without actually meaning to.
Likewise, it’s absolutely okay to put your best into your work. But, do so with
the desire to let your best works glorify the Lord, not yourself.)
A
warning against so-called one-upmanship: “Jealousy and selfishness are not
God’s kind of wisdom. Such things are earthly, unspiritual, and demonic. For
wherever there is jealousy and selfish ambition, there you will find disorder
and evil of every kind” (James 3:15-16, NLT). When we allow ourselves to be “one-uppers,”
to feed our pride, jealousy, and selfishness, we are formulating for ourselves
a kind of “wisdom” that is not based on the goodness, propriety, ability, and
knowledge of God. Essentially, we grow to believe in our own sense, which is
nothing more than impudence, instead of trusting and understanding true wisdom
that comes only from God.
Unfortunately, one-upmanship also
has a devastating domino effect. It moves from the initial one-upper to the “one-upped”
like an infection. For example, once when I created an invitation for a party I
was hosting, a “one-upper” friend, who was also helping host the party but wasn’t
in charge of the invitations, took the invitation I made and completely
redesigned it. Besides the familiar wording, the entire design of the invite
was different. It looked nice, but I also thought that my original design
looked equally nice. I was immediately hurt because that was the one element of
the party I had been given to help with. It was my responsibility, and I put a
lot of thought and effort into creating invitations that the party’s guest of
honor would love. Instead of just letting it go, the polluting effect of one-upmanship
had already contaminated me. She was my rival, and I was bent on besting her at
whatever she did for the party. And, unfortunately (but expectedly), our
friendship was on the rocks for a while after that rivalry party.
One-upmanship can be a very
strong and deadly poison. It tears apart friendships and sisterhood. It
belittles the giftedness of other women. It upholds the worldly value of self
above all. It breeds resentment, frustration, malice, and other evils. It
causes division, creating rivalry where Christ only desires unity in his
Church. It helps us to seek our own glory, without care for God’s. As James
3:16 says, “wherever there is jealousy and selfish ambition, there you will
find disorder and evil of every kind.”
We need to stop competing for
attention. We need to stop turning everyone around us into rivals, into enemies.
That’s what we’re doing when we give in to one-upmanship—we’re assembling a
battleground, where our enemies are our friends and sisters in Christ.
One thing that I’ve learned while
seeking out this topic in the Word and in my times of prayer, is that it’s okay
to be outdone. It’s okay to be outshined! If your works are done with humility,
putting others and God before yourself, then you work wisely (James 3:13). Not
wisely as the world sees, with selfishness and impudence, but with God’s kind
of wisdom. “The wisdom from above is first of all pure. It is also peace
loving, gentle at all times, and willing to yield to others. It is full of
mercy and good deeds. It shows no favoritism and is always sincere. And those
who are peacemakers will plant seeds of peace and reap a harvest of
righteousness” (James 3:17-18). And, in order to work wisely, in order to put aside pride and take on humility, we need to put on our armor. A consistent and intentional time with God is key to armoring us against our temptation to one-up someone. Feed yourself daily with the Word and pray ceaselessly, that you might be strengthened in your fight against temptations and sin.
Lord, help us to be okay with yielding the
spotlight to another—to be okay with being outshined. Help us to be merciful
when we are victims of one-upmanship. Protect us from showing favoritism to our
own works. Build in us a desire to work sincerely for Your glory, Lord. Refashion
our hearts from those of battle makers into those of peacemakers, so that we might
be women after Your own heart.
“Do nothing from rivalry or conceit, but in humility count others more significant than yourselves. Let each of you look not only to his own interests, but also to the interests of others. Have this mind among yourselves, which is yours in Christ Jesus, who, though he was in the form of God, did not count equality with God a thing to be grasped, but made himself nothing, taking the form of a servant, being born in the likeness of men” (Philippians 2:3-11).

